Here in North Mississippi that’s the question everyone seems to be asking. I’m sure they are asking it in other areas such as North Carolina as well.
My impression is that folks just don’t believe they can.
I witnessed the decline of the U.S. Steel Industry first hand. I also participated in the rapid market shifts in the computer and high-tech manufacturing industries.
There are many parallels with the furniture industry and those industries.
So to answer the question, can the U.S. Furniture Industry compete globally?
YES and NO!
If it’s to be business as usual the answer is no. We simply cannot do things the way they’ve been done the past fifty years and compete with the low cost imports from places like China.
Let’s face it, labor at an average of .69 cents an hour, no environmental or worker protection requirements, low overhead, add up to an insurmountable list of obstacles to address head-on and win.
I read recently that one Furniture Trade Organization plans to petition the government to put protective tariffs on imports from China. While action like this is certainly warranted to protect domestic manufacturers against “dumping”, that is selling their products below cost to gain market share, it is never a long term solution. The steel industry has secured government protection on several occasions and instead of using the time and money gained to revamp their operations, they did nothing different, and we all know the result.
So what’s the answer?
First it is to realize that foreign competitors succeed in our market because there is an opportunity to do so in the absence of differentiation.
They simply copy what we make, ship it here and sell it cheaper.
We then compete on that lower price point, and rather than differentiate, we chase them.
Just look at any furniture advertisement, is there anything other than low cost highlighted?
All ignored, just cheap!
I read an article on this very subject a while ago, and the writer quoted the old comic character Pogo, “We have met the enemy and he is us“.
We need to level the playing field.
Start with understanding what we have that the off-shore producers don’t?
The Chinese have low production costs due solely to cheap labor.
Why do we allow them to drive us to compete on the one single advantage they have over us?
It’s time far a strategic renewal of the U.S. Furniture industry. We need to rethink the entire supply chain;
We need to move away from commodity products that are mass produced at lower and lower costs, and develop niche markets that will pay a premium for quick ship, some customization, and quality.
We need to develop strategic supplier agreements and take advantage of the furniture manufacturing clusters that exist around the country.
Simply put we need to develop a market that capitalizes on our strengths and exposes their weaknesses, not continue to try to compete head-on against their one strength.
The U.S. market for home furnishings is the largest in the world and it’s ours. We need to innovate and plan to drive that market, not follow others.
U.S. manufacturers need to take responsibility for their own destiny. We need to define the market, set the standards based on ours strengths and make off-shore manufacturers compete on our terms.
Will it work for the entire market? Of course not. There will always be buyers looking for “cookie cutter” product based solely on price.
But there also has to be a huge market looking for quality goods, with some level of personalization, delivered in a timely fashion. It exists for other products, look at the automotive industry. People buy cars to make a statement about themselves, do we think they wouldn’t furnish and decorate their homes with the same goal in mind?
We need to decide what market we’re in and strategically plan to dominate it.
Author’s Note: Article previously published here.
…
Martin Harshberger is Managing Partner of Measurable Results LLC. Marty specializes in strategic planning, pre- and post-merger integration, as well as business process improvement. He can be reached at 662-844-9088 or by email at: mailto:info@bottomlinecoach.com His new book Bottom Line Focus is available on Amazon and his website: http://www.bottomlinecoach.com/
Read more articles written by Martin Harshberger
Related posts:
- Furniture Feet Add Style, Consistency to Kitchens
A growing trend in the cabinetry industry today has been using furniture feet under counters, islands, and other kitchen fixtures. Using various styles of furniture feet has many advantages for the designer looking to augment the theme of a particular kitchen; from bringing the coziness of the living room into... - How To Restore Old Wood Furniture
Restoring an old piece of wooden furniture can be an involved and tedious process, so it is important to determine what kind of work is truly necessary before you begin. An inexperienced do-it-yourselfer may look at a blemished piece of furniture and assume that it needs to be refinished, when... - The Future of the Office Photocopier Industry
Since Xerox first invented and sold the first commercial photocopy machine companies and organisations have paid for use of the machine on a cost per copy basis. This has traditionally included full maintainance and toner supplied under a service agreement. In-fact the office photocopier is unique in the fact its... - How To Sell Your Products Online And Cash In On What May Be The Only Recession Proof Industry
Tens of thousands of people all over the globe are quietly cashing in on what may be the only recession proof industry — at the very least it’s one of few industries maintaining consistent and enormous growth! These people… well, these are just regular folks who have decided they want... - How MrBean Led the Computer Industry
1955 seemed like any other year to most people, but unbeknown to the world ’55 was to prove the arrival of the geeks. Steve Jobs, Bill Gates, Tim Berners-Lee and Eric Schmidt were all born in 1955. Brilliant author Malcolm Gladwell also noticed this occurrence of the rise of computer... - Travel Industry Management: Scam Alert
If you’ve been around the internet for any period of time, you’re well aware of the scams arriving by email informing you of the vast sums of money you have won. Or, if you help the Nigerian Princess move money out of her country, you can have a cut of... - The Heart-Centered Product That Created a Billion Dollar Industry
As I wrote this article, the film, “Julie and Julia,” has so far, been a quite the summer hit. “Julie and Julia is a light drama that tells the story of New Yorker, Julie Powell who challenged herself to cook every recipe in Julia Child’s famous cookbook: “Mastering the Art... - Clinical Research Consulting, Inc Provides Clinical Research Monitoring Model That is Beneficial to Industry Sponsors
Clinical Research Consulting, Inc. (CRCI) a contract research organization located in Boston, MA continues to attract pharmaceutical industry sponsors to its unique monitoring service model. “Our model is unique and different from many CROs in the industry” states Lisa Mazurka, CRCI’s Founder and President. First, we hire and work with... - Pricing According to the Type of Product
Finding the right price for your product is the key to success, in both the long and the short term. The right price for your product would lie somewhere between the cost and the price a customer is ready to pay for your services. The cost would include the expenses... - How to Evaluate the Quality of a Dietary Supplement
So, you’ve found a Dietary Supplement that exactly fits your special need. The information on the supplier’s website appears to be consistent with everything that you’ve read and heard, and now you’re ready to buy. But there are questions on your mind. “What is the quality of this product that... - Pricing: All You Need to Know
If you are trying to sell something on the Internet, pricing your services/ products would be the single most important decision you will take. Since, the Internet provides thousands of alternatives to the customers, you need to be at par with the competition. The prices that you quite will determine... - Promotional Pricing
Usually promotional pricing are used while launching a new product. It is used to stimulate demand for those products which have a lagging demand. The price target buyers are usually the ones looking for the deal. Some examples of these promotional event pricing are meant for special events. These are... - Change Prices to Make Your Offerings More Appealing
The days when men swore by Gillette, and women didn’t look beyond Guerlain are long gone. There are rarely any monopolies in the world market, and every product in the economy has a competitor, a substitute that is constantly trying to outdo the other. The most common basis for competition... - Price Skimming As a Pricing Strategy
Of all the marketing strategies you will use in your business, the pricing strategy is one of the most important. Along with choosing the right product, intelligent marketing, and a sound sales plan the correct price strategy will determine your revenues and market share. Usually the leaders in their industry... - Time To Think Made In America
It is estimated that there are approximately 293 million people currently living in the United States and if each one would change only $20 a month in their spending from imported products and instead purchased American made products, it might well create as many as 5 million new jobs. Certainly...