The mysterious “Google Sandbox” has been a hot discussion topic for search engine optimizers since the phenomena was first noted and named in late April 2004 (http://forums.seochat.com/t9919/s.html). Since then, ideas on the function, scope and even existence of the sandbox have been a mainstay in SEO and Google related forums, chats and articles.
The term, “sandbox” describes a process of Google’s ranking formulas that appear to slow the debut of new sites in the Top10 listings. Whether or not the sandbox exists tends to depend on the side of the black hat / white hat debate one comes from. SEOs dedicated to “pure”, non-spammy SEO tend to downplay the effects of the sandbox while those who use dark-art tactics know from personal experience that the effects are very real.
In a November 2005 interview (http://www.seroundtable.com/archives/002809.html) with WebmasterWorld’s Brett Tabke, Google chief engineer Matt Cutts appeared to acknowledge it saying, “How many feel there is no such thing as a sandbox? SEOs normally split down the line. There are some things in the algorithm that may be perceived as a sandbox that doesn’t apply to all industries.”
While Matt’s comments did not exactly confirm or deny the existence of a sandbox, they did leave the barn door open wide enough for a great deal of discussion. Between November 2005 and September 2006, well over 300 credible articles, forum threads and blog posts have addressed the topic.
For some, such as Search Engine Guide editor Jennifer Laycock, the Google sandbox is an expression of importance and credibility imbued upon sites that have established themselves over time in Google’s index. In a June 2006 article (http://www.searchengineguide.com/laycock/007705.html), Jennifer wrote, “… there is no Google sandbox! It simply doesn’t exist.”
When new sites are spidered and brought into the index, Google compares them with similar sites already in its index and makes a judgment on the relevance of that site against the others. “After all,” she wrote, “how many mortgage application sites does Google really need to list? Why should they think that your brand new mortgage site is any more worthy of a ranking than the 1.5 million (yes, MILLION) sites that are already indexed for the phrase ‘mortgage application.’”
Jennifer wrote her piece in agreement with a post Sheri Thurow from Grantastic Design made to LED Digest (issue 2177) where Sheri proclaimed, “There is no such thing as a Google Sandbox. It’s one of those terms that self-proclaimed search engine “experts” came up with to explain why their methodologies don’t work.”
Sheri’s post generated a great deal of controversy, partially because it was perceived by readers as a rant. She explained her point by writing, “A search-friendly Web site is built on a solid foundation of keyword-focused text and giving spiders a means of accessing that text. Then, objective 3rd parties should basically confirm what you say about your own content. It has been this way for years. For that reason, no Google Sandbox. If your site doesn’t have the foundation, its pages won’t appear in search engine results.”
What Jennifer and Sheri are saying is Google is not going to automatically give a first page listing to a new site, no matter how well optimized that site might be. There might be thousands or even millions of competing websites being compared against a site that has not had time to establish itself as a peer-referenced site.
Peer referencing is an important cornerstone of Google’s overall ranking formula. Originally, Google built its search results based on the number of links directed to a specific document from other web documents. As technology progressed, the creation and maintenance of web documents became infinitely easier, especially with the deployment of blogs. Driving the creation of millions of fresh documents, sites and blogs was the popularization of Google’s paid search advertising distribution program AdSense. Suddenly, a direct profit motive existed for some in the SEO sector to use their knowledge and immense talents to game Google’s SERPs six ways to Sunday.
Links, which have long been like gold for search savvy webmasters, became increasingly important following the series of algorithm upgrades that started with Hilltop in the summer of 2004. Since that time, Google has raced to keep up with a myriad of methods devised to game its ranking methods. The implementation of a critical measure of how a site, or a document originating at a specific domain, has established itself along side similar sites and/or documents, is accepted by most SEOs as a long leg in Google’s race against manipulation of their search results.
Google has consistently moved to limit link-based exploits of its link-based organic ranking system. Starting this time last year, it implemented a series of measurements examining a wide assortment of data about documents in its index, along with data derived from linking documents known as the Jagger update.
It is safe to say that for the past two years, the majority of research and advancement in the field of search engine optimization comes from the study and analysis of link structures. When it comes to getting a strong ranking on Google and to a lesser degree, on Yahoo, link partners are as well scrutinized as the specific page or domain being indexed.
One of the newer clich
Related posts:
- Who’s Linking to Your Web Site – and What Does That Say About You to Google?
Linking is the mechanism that connects all the pages on the Internet. You’ve got links throughout your web site to let people navigate their way around. You may have links going out to other web sites that you think will be useful for your visitors. And hopefully you have links... - How To Reverse Engineer My #1 Google Rankings
To many online marketers, getting a #1 listing on Google for your target keyword phrases is “heaven.” It does lead to many times more traffic than being even #2 or #3. If you’re not on the first page of Google, you may as well forget getting any significant traffic in... - The Photocopier,The Firewall and Google
China, following on from its censorship of the Internet, has identified photocopiers in Tibet as a potential threat to the state. Fearing what BEIJING may class as demagogic machinations, a new law has been introduced that requires the owners of printing and photocopying shops to obtain a permit. They will... - Critical Steps to Successful Sales Lead Generation in Google
Some website owners are more frustrated about Google optimization than for other search engines. They feel it is harder to perform search engine optimization for Google. Whether you are making direct sales from your website or sales lead generation (or both), optimizing for Google doesn’t need to be that hard.... - New Search Engines – Can Anyone Beat Google?
Can any new search engine beat Google, probably not, mainly because Google isn’t going anywhere but up. It is the dominant search engine with around 72 percent of U.S. online searches and its percentages are much higher in other parts of the world. (Source: Hitwise) However, there are some serious... - What Kind Of Backlinks Are Best At Helping Your Website In Google?
I was in the Warrior Forum, and someone asked what kinds of Backlinks are worth pursuing. This is my answer to that query. As an article marketing guy, I bet you can guess my answer. The answer is that you should have links everywhere your potential clients are looking to... - 10 Steps To Top 10 Rankings In Google
Most webmasters go totally “gaga” for top 10 rankings in Google. And for good reason, Google is the most dominant search engine on the net and will deliver the largest amount of traffic. Even those webmasters who are fortunate enough to get No. 1 rankings for their keywords in all... - How Many Links Does It Take To Get To The Middle Of Google Page One?
Everyday it seems, people are asking me the optimum numbers of inbound links they need to acquire for their website in order to rank well in Google. My answer is going to seem a little flip, but it is the honest, best answer. Answer: You need more inbound links –... - Supercharge Your Internet Marketing Using the Improved Google Keyword Tool
As an Internet Marketing Consultant, I know that whether using pay-per-click (PPC) or organic search engine optimization (SEO), the process begins with our research keyword. This is true whether you’re doing your work yourself or working with an SEO Consultant. The search engine ranking for our chosen keywords consumes us,... - My Opinion on Google Adwords
Over the past 5 or 6 years I have made some pretty good cash-flow out of google adwords. For those of you who aren’t aware, here’s how it works. You place links on google adwords. People click on those links. Those visitors come to your web site. You convert them... - Marketing Tip: A Google Adwords Strategy That Makes More Cents
My online associates frequently give me a hard time, trying to convince me that I give away far too much free information… They tell me that I should keep more of my more profitable strategies to myself — well, at least between us anyway… LOL When I share many of... - Is Yahoo Under the Influence of TrustRank?
As you travel the vast world of search engine results among Google, Yahoo, and MSN, you are likely to run into junk pages at some point in your journey. Although the search engines are working daily to improve search engine results, the search engine spammers are working just as hard... - Never Underestimate The Real Power Of Long-Tail Keywords
Before 2010, May Day simply referred to May 1st, a celebration of the beginning of Spring, or International Workers’ Day (Labour Day), as practiced in many countries, most notably in Russia… The alternate spelling Mayday was a signal used by ships’ captains and airplane pilots to announce “Come and Help... - Marketing Coaching: Understanding the Basics of Page Rank
You’ve just built your website and you want to show up on the search engines. You start reading about SEO and one of the first things that jumps out at you is something called “Google PageRank.” You know about the big dog of the search engines, but what is PageRank... - Link Building in Online Marketing: Tougher Than It Sounds
You probably don’t need to read the latest advice from the online marketing consultants to figure out the basic idea behind link building. Without links, your site won’t develop authority. Without authority, it won’t move up on the search engines. But even the most savvy online marketing consultant would have...